We implement an agent-based simulation of the response threshold model of reproductive division of labor. Ants in our simulation must perform two tasks in their environment: forage and reproduce. The colony is capable of allocating ant resources to these roles using different division of labor strategies via genetic architectures and plasticity mechanisms. We find that the deterministic allocation strategy of the response threshold model is more robust than the probabilistic allocation strategy. The deterministic allocation strategy is also capable of evolving complex solutions to colony problems like niche construction and recovery from the loss of the breeding caste. In addition, plasticity mechanisms had both positive and negative influence on the emergence of reproductive division of labor. The combination of plasticity mechanisms has an additive and sometimes emergent impact.