This article starts with the observation that in the context of extremely heterogeneous gender regimes within and among EU member states, the European Union is progressively institutionalizing equality policy at the supranational level. The argument advanced to explain the puzzle as to why gender policy development in the EU apparently escapes the ‘joint decision trap’ (Scharpf 1988) highlights gender differences in public EU support. It is claimed that explanations of policy changes in the EU after Maastricht have to take into account mass public ‘Euroskepticism’ and, in particular, ‘gender gaps’ in EU support, and to identify their sources and impacts in the processes of EU governance. By using Eurobarometer data this study explores whether cross-national variation in gendered EU support can be explained primarily by sociodemographic characteristics of individual respondents or by variables situated at the level of member states or whether factors related to the EU’s democratic performance are the decisive ones. In the conclusion propositions are formulated regarding the mechanisms why gender differences in EU support can be expected to impact European governance.
References
Abels
, Gabriele
(1998
) ‘Engendering the representational democratic deficit in the European Union
’, Working Paper, Wissenschaftszentrum Berlin, FS II 98–106.Abramson
, Paul R.
and Inglehart
, Ronald
(1998
) ‘Comparing European publics
’, American Political Science Review
1
:185
–90
.Anderson
, Christopher
and Kaltenthaler
, Karl
(1996
) ‘The dynamics of public opinion toward European integration, 1973–1993
’, European Journal of International Relations
2
: 175
–99
.Banaszak
, Lee Ann
and Plutzer
, Eric
(1993
) ‘Contextual determinants of feminist attitudes: national and subnational influences in western Europe
’, American Political Science Review
1
:29
–53
.Biester
, Elke B.
, Holland-Kunz
, Jansen
, Mechtild
, Maleck-Lewy
, Eva
, Ruf Anja
and Sauer
, Birgit
(eds) (1994
) Das unsichtbare Gescblecht der Europa. Der europäische Einigungsprozeß aus feministischer Sicht
, Opladen
: Leske + Budrich
.Borchorst
, Anette
(1995
) ‘A political niche: Denmark’s Equal Status Council’, in Dorothy McBride
Stetson
and Amy G.
Mazur
(eds) Comparative State Feminism
, London and New Delhi
: Sage
, pp. 59
–75
.Dahlerup
, Drude
(1996
) ‘Demokratiets fremtid I et europaeisk kvindeperspektiv’, in KVINFO, Kvindeoffentlighed I Europa,
Copenhagen.Dalton
, Russell J.
and Eichenberg
, Richard C.
(1991
) ‘Economic evaluations and citizens’ support for European integration
’, Paper presented at the 1991 APSA- Meeting, Washington DC.Dehousse
, Renaud
(1998
) ‘European institutional architecture after Amsterdam: parliamentary system or regulatory structure?
’, Common Market Law Review
2
: 595
–627
.De Vaus
, David
and McAllister
, Ian
(1989
) ‘The changing politics of women: gender and political alignment in 11 nations
’, European Journal of Political Research
17
:241
–62
.Duncan
, Simon
(1996
) ‘Obstacles to a successful equal opportunities policy in the European Union
’, The European Journal of Women’s Studies
4
:399
–422
.Eichenberg
, R. C.
and Dalton
, R.J.
(1997
) ‘Convergence and divergence in citizen support for European integration, 1973–1996
’, Paper presented at the 1997 APSA-Meeting, Washington DC.Elman
, R. Amy
(1995
) ‘The state’s equality for women. Sweden’s equality ombudsman’, in Dorothy McBride
Stetson
and Amy G.
Mazur
(eds), Comparative State Feminism
, London and New Delhi
: Sage
, pp. 237
–53
.Elman
, R. Amy
(ed.) (1996
) Sexual Politics and the European Union. The New Feminist Challenge
, Providence, Oxford
: Berghahn Books
.European Commission
(1983
) Women and Men of Europe in 1983; The Situation of Women, Women and Employment, Their Role in Society
(EB 19).European Commission
(1990
) European Public Opinion on the Family and the Desire for Children
(EB 32).European Commission
(1991
) Family and Employment within the Twelve
(EB Special).European Commission
(1993
) Europeans and the Family
(EB 39).European Commission
(1995
) Handbook on Equal Treatment of Men and Women in the European Community,
Brussels, Luxemburg.European Commission
(1997a
) Women and Men in Europe: Equal Opportunities?
(EB 44.3).European Commission
(1997b
) Women’s Attitudes to the European Union. A Typology of Public Opinion among Europe’s Women
(EB No. 47.1; by Daphne Ahrendt).European Network of Experts
(1994
, 2nd edn) Women in Decision-Making. Facts and Figures on Women in Political and Public Decision-Making in Europe
, Brussels
: European Commission
.European Women’s Lobby (EWL)
(1996
) Contribution to the Intergovernmental Conference 1996. Revised Articles of the Maastricht Treaty. Proposals,
Brussels.European Women’s Lobby
(1998
) A General Introduction to the European Women’s Lobby,
February (http://www.womenlobby.org).Falkner
, Gerda
(1994
) Supranationalität trotz Einstimmigkeit. Entscbeidungsmuster der EU am Beispiel Sozialpolitik
, Bonn
: Europa Union Verlag
.Finifter
, Ada W.
(1995
) Public Opinion, in Seymour M.
Lipset
(ed.), The Encyclopaedia of Democracy
, Washington DC
: Congressional Quarterly
.Flynn
, Pádraig
, Commissioner of the DGV, Employment, Industrial Relations and Social Affairs
(1998
) Speech to the Women’s Committee,
European Parliament, 21 January (http://europa.eu.int/comm/dg05/speeches).Föllesdal
, Andreas
and Koslowski
, P.
(eds) (1998
) Democracy and the European Union
, Berlin
: Springer Verlag
.Gabel
, Matthew
(1998a
) Interests and Integration: Market Liberalization, Public Opinion, and European Union
, Ann Arbor, Michigan
: University of Michigan Press
.Gabel
, Matthew
(1998b
) ‘Public support for European integration: an empirical test of five theories
’, The Journal of Politics
2
: 333
–54
.Gabel
, Matthew
(1998c
) ‘Economic integration and mass politics: market liberalization and public attitudes in the European Union
’, American Journal of Political Science
42
(3
).Gabel
, Matthew
and Palmer
, Harvey D.
(1995
) ‘Understanding variation in public support for European integration
’, European Journal of Political Research
27
:3
–19
.Gabel
, Matthew
and Whitten
, Guy D.
(1997
) ‘Economic conditions, economic perceptions, and public support for European integration
’, Political Behavior
19
(1
): 81
–96
..Grönbech-Jensen
, Carsten
(1998
) ‘The Scandinavian tradition of open government and the European Union: problems of compatibility?
’, Journal of European Public Policy
1
:185
–99
.Hayes
, Bernadette C.
, McAllister
, Ian
and Studlar
, Donley T.
(1996
) ‘Gender, feminism and postmaterialist attitudes: a cross-national analysis
’, Paper presented at the 1996 APSA Meeting, San Francisco, CA.Helfferich
, Barbara
(1998
) ‘Frauenpolitische Arbeit im Integrationsprozeß: Die Aktivitäten der Europäischen Frauenlobby im Kontext der Regierungskonfer- enz
’, femina politica. Zeitschrift für feministische Politik-Wissenschaft
2
:35
–44
.Hoecker
, Beate
(ed.) (1998
) Handbuch Politische Partizipation von Frauen in Europa
, Opladen
, Leske + Budrich
.Hoskyns
, Catherine
(1996a
) Integrating Gender. Women, Law and Politics in the European Union
, London and New York
: Verso
.Hoskyns
, Catherine
(1996b
) ‘The European Union and the women within: an overview of women’s rights policy
’, in Amy
Elman
(ed.), Sexual Politics in the European Union
, pp. 13
–22
.Hoskyns
, Catherine
(1999
) ‘Gender and transnational democracy: the case of the European Union’, in Mary K.
Meyer
and Elisabeth
Prügl
(eds), Gender Politics in Global Governance
, Boston, MA
: Rowman & Littlefield
, pp. 72
–87
.Inglehart
, Ronald
(1970
) ‘The new Europeans: inward or outward looking
’, International Organization
1
:129
–39
.Inglehart
, Ronald
(1977
) ‘Long term trends in mass support for European integration
’, Government and Opposition
2
: 150
–77
.Inglehart
, Ronald
(1997
) Modernization and Postmodernization. Cultural, Economic, and Political Change in 43 Societies
, Princeton, NJ
: Princeton University Press
.Inglehart
, Ronald
and Norris
, Pippa
(1998
) ‘Gender gaps in voting behaviour in global perspective
’, Paper presented at the 1998 APSA Meeting, Boston, MAInterparliamentary Union (IPU)
(1997
) Men and Women in Politics-Democracy still in the Making. A World Comparative Study.
Series Reports and Documents No 28, Geneva.Jachtenfuchs
, Markus
(1998
) ‘Democracy and governance in the European Union’, in A.
Föllesdal
and P.
Koslowski
(eds), Democracy and the European Union
, Berlin
: Springer Verlag
.Jelen
, Ted G.
, Thomas
, Sue
and Wilcox
, Clyde
(1994
) ‘The gender gap in comparative perspective. Gender differences in abstract ideology and concrete issues in Western Europe
’, European Journal of Political Research
5
:171
–86
.Keck
, Margaret E.
and Sikkink
, Kathryn
(1995
) ‘Transnational issue networks in international polities’, in Activists Without Borders: Transnational Issue Networks in International Politics
, WP Series No. 4, Ann Arbor
: University of Michigan
.Klingemann
, Hans Dieter
and Fuchs
, Dieter
(eds) (1995
) Citizens and the State
, Oxford
: Oxford University Press
.Kohler-Koch
, Beate
(1996
) ‘Catching up with change: the transformation of governance in the European Union
’, Journal of European Public Policy
3
:359
–80
.Kohler-Koch
, Beate
(1998
) ‘Die Europäisierung nationaler Demokratien: Verschleiß eines europäischen Kulturerbes?’, in Michael
Greven
(ed.), Demokratie - eine Kultur des Western?
, Opladen
, Leske + Budrich
.Kohler-Koch
, Beate
and Eising
, Rainer
(eds) (1998
) The Transformation of Governance in the European Union
(forthcoming).Lane
, Jan-Erik
and Ersson
, Svante O.
(1996
) European Politics. An Introduction
, London
: Sage
.Lawler
, Peter
(1997
) ‘Scandinavian exceptionalism and the European Union
’, Journal of Common Market Studies
4
.Leibfried
, Stefan
and Pierson
, Paul
(eds) (1995
) European Social Policy – Between Fragmentation and Integration
, Washington, DC
: The Brookings Institution
.Liebert
, Ulrike
(1997
) The Gendering of Euro-Skepticism: Public Discourses and Support for the EU in a Cross-National Comparison
, Working Paper No. 97.2, Institute for European Studies, Ithaca, NY
: Cornell University
.Liebert
, Ulrike
(1998
) ‘Der ‘gender gap’ in der Europäischen Öffentlichkeit als Problem der international vergleichenden Meinungsforschung’, in Thomas
König
, Elmar
Rieger
and Hermann
Schmitt
(eds), Europa der Bürger? Voraussetzungen, Alternativen, Konsequenzen
, Frankfurt am Main
: Campus
.Lindberg
, Leon N.
and Scheingold
, Stuart A
(1970
) Europe’s Would-Be Polity
, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
: Prentice Hall
.Lindbom
, Anders
(1998
) ‘Institutional legacies and the role of citizens in the Scandinavian welfare state’, Scandinavian Political Studies 2
1 (2).Locher-Dodge
, Birgit
(1999
) ‘“Identitätsexperiment” Europa: Nationalstaat, Geschlecht und supranationale Integration’, in Eva
Kreisky
and Birgit
Sauer
(eds), Das ‘Geschlecht’ des Staates. Transformation von Staatlichkeit in der Euro-päischen Union
, Vienna
: Böhlau Verlag
.Lundmark
, Carina
(1995
) ‘Feminist political orientations’, in Jan W.
van Deth
and Elinor
Scarbrough
(eds), The Impact of Values
, Oxford
: Oxford University Press
, pp. 250
–74
.Lundstrom
, Karin
(1997
) ‘Women caught in a logical trap in EC Law: an analysis of the use of quotas in the case of Kalanke’, in A World in Transition. Feminist Perspectives in International Relations,
Statsvetenskaplig Tidskrift 1, Lund, pp. 74
–86
.McBride Stetson
, Dorothy
and Mazur
, Amy
(eds) (1995
) Comparative State Feminism
, London
: Sage
.Majone
, Giandomenico
(1989
) ‘Regulating Europe: problems and prospects
’, Jahrbuch zur Staats- und Verwaltungswissenschaft
3
:159
–77
.Majone
, Giandomenico
(1998
) ‘Europe’s “democracy deficit”: the question of standards
’, European Law Journal
1
:5
–28
.Mancini
, G. Federicp
(1998
) ‘Europe: the case of statehood
’, European Law Journal
1
:29
–42
.Marsh
, Michael
and Norris
, Pippa
(eds) (1997
) Political Representation in the European Parliament
. European Journal of Political Research
2
, Special Issue.Mazey
, Sonia
(1988
) ‘European Community action on behalf of women: the limits of legislation
’, Journal of Common Market Studies
1
:63
–84
.Mazey
, Sonia
(1995
) ‘The development of EU equality policies: bureaucratic expansion on behalf of women?
’, Public Administration
4
:591
–610
.Mazey
, Sonia
(1998
) ‘The European Union and women’s rights: from the Europeanization of national agendas to the nationalization of a European agenda?
’, Journal of European Public Policy
1
:131
–52
.Meehan
, Elizabeth
(1993
) Citizenship and the European Community
, London
: Sage
.Morokvasic
, Mirjana
(1991
) ‘Fortress Europe and migrant women
’, Feminist Review
39
:69
–84
.Mueller
, Carol M.
(ed.) (1988
) The Politics of the Gender Gap. The Social Construction of Influence
, London
: Sage
.Mushaben
, Joyce Marie
(1994
) ‘The other “Democratic Deficit”. Women in the European Community before and after Maastricht’, in Michael
Luetzeler
(ed.), Europe after Maastricht. American and European Perspectives
, Oxford
: Providence Press
.Niedermayer
, Oscar
and Sinnott
, Richard
(eds) (1995
) Public Opinion and Internationalized Governance
, Oxford
: Oxford University Press
.Norris
, Pippa
(1997
) ‘Representation and the Democratic deficit
’, in Michael
Marsh
and Pippa
Norris
(eds), Political Representation in the European Parliament. European Journal of Political Research
2
, Special Issue: 273
–82
.Ostner
, Ilona
and Lewis
, Jane
(1995
) ‘Gender and the evolution of European social policies’, in Stefan
Leibfried
and Paul
Pierson
(eds), European Social Policy -Between Fragmentation and Integration
, Washington DC
: The Brookings Institution
, pp. 159
–93
.Petersen
, Nikolaj
(1998
) ‘Review article: small states in European integration
’, Scandinavian Political Studies
1
.Pierson
, Paul
(1996
) ‘The path to European integration - a historical institutionalist analysis
’, Comparative Political Studies
2
:123
–63
.Pierson
, Paul
and Leibfried
, Stephan
(1995
) ‘Multitiered institutions and the making of social policy’, in Stephan
Leibfried
and Paul
Pierson
(eds), European Social Policy - Between Fragmentation and Integration
, Washington DC
: The Brookings Institution
, pp. 1
–40
.Rabier
, Jacques-René
(1989
) ‘L’opinion publique et L’integration de L’Europe dans les années 1950’, in Groupes de Liaison des Historiens auprès des Communautés
(ed.), La Relance européenne et les Traités de Rome
, Brussels
: Giuffré
.Reif
, Karlheinz
(1993a
) ‘Cultural diversity as factors in European identity’, in Soledad
Garcia
(ed.), European Identity and the Search for Legitimacy
, London
: Pinter
.Reif
, Karlheinz
(1993b
) ‘Das Demokratiedefizit der EG und die Chancen zu seiner Verringerung
’, Politische Bildung
3
.Reif
, Karlheinz
and Inglehart
, Ronald
(eds) (1991
) Eurobarometer. The Dynamics of European Public Opinion
, London
: St Martin’s Press
.Rosch Inglehart
, Marita
(1991
) ‘Gender differences in sex-role attitudes: a topic without a future?,’ in Karlheinz
Reif
and Ronald
Inglehart
(eds), Eurobarometer. The Dynamics of European Public Opinion
, London
: St Martin’s Press
, pp. 187
–200
.Rossilli
, Mariagrazia
(1997
) ‘The European Community’s policy on the equality of women. From the Treaty of Rome to the present
’, The European Journal of Women’s Studies
4
:63
–82
.Sainsbury
, Diane
(1996
) Gender Equality and Welfare States,
Cambridge-Cambridge University Press.Saraceno
, Chiara
(1997
) ‘Gender and Europe: national differences, resources, and impediments to the construction of a common interest by European women’, in Jytte
Klausen
and Louise A.
Tilly
(eds), European Integration in Social and Historical Perspective, 1850 to the Present
, New York
: Rowman & Littlefield
, pp. 249
–66
.Sbragia
, Alberta
(1994
) ‘From “nation-state” to “member-state”: the evolution of the European Community’, in Peter Michael
Luetzeler
(ed.), Europe after Maastricht. American and European Perspectives
, Oxford
: Providence
, pp. 69
–88
.Scharpf
, Fritz W.
(1988
) ‘The joint-decision trap: lessons from German Federalism and European integration
’, Public Administration
3
:239
–78
.Scharpf
, Fritz W.
(1997
) ‘Economic integration, democracy and the welfare state
’, Journal of European Public Policy
1
:18
–36
.Schmidt
, Vivien A.
(1997
) ‘Discourse and (dis)integration in Europe: the cases of France, Great Britain, and Germany
’, Daedalus
3
:167
–98
.Schmidt
, Vivien A.
(1998
) ‘Democracy and discourse in an integrating Europe and a globalizing world. Globalization, Europeanization and political economy in Europe
’, mimeo, University of Berkeley, April.Schmitter
, Philippe
(1998
) ‘Is it really possible to democratize the Euro-polity?’, in Andreas
Föllesdal
and P.
Koslowski
(eds), Democracy and the European Union
, Berlin
: Springer Verlag
, pp. 13
–36
.Schunter-Kleemann
(ed.) (1992
) Herrenhaus Europa - Geschlechterverhältnisse im Wohlfahrtsstaat
, Berlin
: edition sigma
.Schunter-Kleemann
(1993
) ‘Geschlechterdifferenz in der politischen Debatte zur europäischen Union
’, PROKLA: Zeitschrift für Kritiscbe Soziahvissenschaft
92/23
:452
–72
.Sinnott
, Richard
(1995
) ‘Bringing public opinion back in’, in Oskar
Niedermayer
and Richard
Sinnott
(eds), Public Opinion and Internationalized Governance
, Oxford
: Oxford University Press
, pp. 11
–32
.Springer
, Beverly
(1992
) ‘What 1992 means for European women’, in The Social Dimension of 1992: Europe Faces a New EC
, London
: Greenwood Press
, pp. 64
–81
.Studlar
, Donley T.
, McAllister
, Ian
and Hayes
, Bernadette C.
(1998
) ‘Explaining the gender gap in voting: a cross-national analysis
’, Social Science Quarterly
79
(4
): 779
–98
..Taggart
, Paul
(1998
) ‘A touchstone of dissent: Euroscepticism in contemporary western European party systems
’, European Journal of Political Research
33
:363
–88
.Tarrow
, Sidney
(1998
) Building a Composite Polity: Popular Contention in the European Union
, Institute for European Studies Working Paper 98.3, Ithaca, NY
: Cornell University
.Thurner
, Paul W.
(1997
) ‘Nationale öffentliche Meinungen und international Verhandlungssysteme. Die Regierungskonferenz 1996’, in Rudolf
Hrbek
(ed.), Die Reform der Europäischen Union. Positionen und Perspektiven der Regierungskonferenz
, Baden-Baden
: Nomos
, pp. 187
–202
.Topf
, Richard
(1995
) ‘Electoral participation’, in Hans-Dieter
Klingemann
and Dieter
Fuchs
(eds), Citizens and the State
, Oxford
: Oxford University Press
.United Nations Development Programme (UNDP)
(1995
) Human Development Report 1995
, New York, Oxford
: UN
.Van Deth
, Jan
(1996
), ‘Politisches Interesse und Apathie in Europa’, in Thomas
König
, Elmar
Rieger
and Hermann
Schmitt
(eds), Das europäische Mehrebenen-system
, Frankfurt
: Campus
.Van Deth
, Jan
and Scarbrough
, Elinor
(eds) (1995
) The Impact of Values
, Oxford
: Oxford University Press
.Vogel-Polsky
, Eliane
(1992
) ‘La democratie paritaire: vers un nouveau contratsocial’, in Actas do Seminario Construir a Igualdade,
Lisboa, 28–30 May, pp. 53
–76
.Weiler
, Josef
(1995
) ‘Does Europe need a constitution? Demos, Telos and the German Maastricht decision
’, European Law Journal
3
:219
–58
.Weiler
, Josef
(1998
) ‘Europe: the case against the case of statehood
’, European Law Journal
1
:43
–62
.Weiler
, Josef
, Haltern
, U.R.
and Mayer
, F.C.
(1995
) ‘European democracy and its critique
’, in Jack
Hayward
(ed.), The Crisis of Representation in Europe, West European Politics
, Special Issue 3–4.Wessels
, Bernhard
(1995
) ‘Development of support: diffusion or demographic replacement?
’, in Oskar
Niedermayer
and Richard
Sinnott
(eds), Public Opinion and Internationalized Governance
, pp. 105
–37
.Whitten
, Guy D.
, Palmer
, Harvey D.
and Gabel
, Matthew
(1998
) ‘”Euro-Pork” and European integration: how European Union fiscal policies influence public support
’, Paper presented at the 1998 APSA Meeting, Boston, 3–6 September.Wolff
, R.
(1993
) ‘Dann stehen wir in Europa ganz allein’, in Die Tageszeitung (TAZ),
p. 133
.Young
, Brigitte
(1999
) ‘Disciplinary neoliberalism in the European Union and gender polities’, New Political Economy
(forthcoming).Zaller
, John R.
(1992
) Nature and Origins of Mass Opinion
, Cambridge
: Cambridge University Press
.Ulrike Liebert is a Professor at the University of Bremen.
© 1999 Taylor & Francis Ltd
1999
Taylor & Francis Ltd
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the use is non-commercial and the original work is properly cited. For a full description of the license, please visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/legalcode.