Backhouse has crafted an outstanding book that is, on one level, a micro-analysis of how one run-of-the-mill interaction between a youth and a police officer metamorphosized into one of the most significant legal cases in Canadian history. On another level, it is a macro-analysis of how the Canadian legal system and Canadian society in general is saturated by, and at the same time struggles with, anti-Black racism.
On October 17, 1993, Rodney Darren Small, a fifteen-year-old Black youth, found himself in an altercation with a white police officer in Halifax, Nova Scotia. Subsequently, the prosecutor brought three charges against Small. During the trial, youth court Judge Corrine Sparks, the first Black female judge appointed in Canada, acquitted the youth, noting in part that “sometimes white police officers overreact.” This led to a successful appeal by the Crown on the basis of actual bias by the judge against the police officer....