The earlier article gives lower bounds on the VC-dimension of various smoothly parameterized function classes. The results were proved by showing a relationship between the uniqueness of decision boundaries and the VC-dimension of smoothly parameterized function classes. The proof is incorrect; there is no such relationship under the conditions stated in the article. For the case of neural networks with tanh activation functions, we give an alternative proof of a lower bound for the VC-dimension proportional to the number of parameters, which holds even when the magnitude of the parameters is restricted to be arbitrarily small.

We examine the relationship between the VC dimension and the number of parameters of a threshold smoothly parameterized function class. We show that the VC dimension of such a function class is at least k if there exists a k -dimensional differentiable manifold in the parameter space such that each member of the manifold corresponds to a different decision boundary. Using this result, we are able to obtain lower bounds on the VC dimension proportional to the number of parameters for several thresholded function classes including two-layer neural networks with certain smooth activation functions and radial basis functions with a gaussian basis. These lower bounds hold even if the magnitudes of the parameters are restricted to be arbitrarily small. In Valiant's probably approximately correct learning framework, this implies that the number of examples necessary for learning these function classes is at least linear in the number of parameters.