Abstract
Some methods of unofficial intervention in protracted intercommunal conflict fail to consider the impact of power asymmetry on the dynamics of conflict and the predictably divergent goals that lower- and higher-power groups seek in unofficial meetings. As a result, third parties face the dilemma of trying to satisfy seemingly irreconcilable goals of the conflicting parties. This article examines asymmetry of goals and the further dilemmas it creates in choosing the level of discourse in unofficial meetings, and in recruiting participants. The authors propose a more proactive research focus on the dynamics of power asymmetry and advance a three-phase strategy for practitioners to deal with the dilemmas of intervening in asymmetrical conflict.
REFERENCES
Amir
. Y.
1976
. The role of intergroup contact in change of prejudice and ethnic relations
. In Towards the elimination of racism
, edited by
P.
Katz
New York
: Pergamon
.
Amir
, Y.
, and
R.
Ben Ari
. 1987
. Meetings between Arab and Jewish youth in Israiel
.
Managemnt
30
: 305
–315
.
Bargal
, D.
1992
. Conflict management workshops for Arab Palestinian and Jewish Youth ‐ A frame‐work for planning, intervention, and evaluation
.
Social Work With Groups
15
(1
):51
–68
.
Bargal
. D.
and
H.
Bar
. 1992
. An approach to intergroup workshops for Arab‐Plaestinian and Jewish youth
.
Journal of Social Issues
48
(2
):139
–154
.
Burton
, J. W.
1987
. Conflict: Resolution and prevention
.
New York
: St. Martin's Press
.
Kartz
. I.
, and
M.
Kahanoff
. 1990
. Dilemmas in facilitating workshops between Arab and Jewish participants in Israel
.
Megamol
33
(1
):29
–47
.
Kelman
, H. C.
1979
An interactional approach to conflict resolution and its application to Israeli‐Palestinian relations
.
International Interactions
6
: 99
–122
.
Kretzmer
, D.
1990
. The legal status of the Arabs in Israel
.
Boulder
,
Colo.
: Westview
.
Maoz
, I.
1995
. A case study of Arab‐Jewish encounters in Israel
.
Paper presented at the Eighth Annual Conference of the International Association for Conflict Management (and the Second Conference of the Ethnic Studies Network), June 11–14, Elsionore, Denmark
.
Miller
, N.
and
M.
Brewer
. 1984
Groups in contact: The psychlogy of desegregation
.
San Diego
; Academic Press
.
Mitchell
, C. R.
1991
. Classifying conflicts: Asymmetry and Resolution
.
The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Scince
518
: 23
–38
.
Peled
, Y.
1992
. Ethnic democracy and the legal construction of citizenship: Arab citizens of the Jewish state
.
American Political and Science Review
86
: 432
–443
.
Rouhana
, N. N.
1997
. Indentities in conflict: Plastinian citizens in an ethnic Jewish State
. In Press.
New Haven
: Yale University Press
.
Rouhana
, N. N.
and
S. T.
Fiske
. 1995
. Perception of power, threat, and conflict intensity in asymetric intergroup conflict
.
Journal of Conflict Resolution
39
: 49
–81
.
Rouhana
, N. N.
and
H. C.
Kelman
. 1994
. Promoting joint thinking in internatonal conflicts: An Israeli‐Palestinian continuing workshop
Journal of Social Issues
50
: 157
–178
.
Smooha
, S.
1984
. The orientation and politicization of the Arab minority in Israel
.
Haifa
: University of Haifa
.
Smooha
, S.
1991
. Minority status in an ethnic democracy: The status of the Arab minority in Israiel
.
Ethnic and Racial studies
13
(3
):389
–413
.
Smooha
, S.
1992
. Arabs and Jews in mutual intolerance
, Vol. 2
.
Boulder
,
Colo.
: Westview Press
.
Stephan
, W. G.
, and
C. W.
Stephan
1996
. Intergroup Relations
.
Madison
,
Wis.
: Brown & Bench‐mark Publishers
.
Suleiman
, R.
1996
. Planned meetings between Israeli Jews and Israeli Palestinians as microcosm: Social psychlogical aspects
.
Unpublished manuscript, Department of Psychlogy, Haifa University
.
Tsemach
, M.
1980
. The attitudes of the Jewish majority towards the Arab minority
.
Jerusalem
: The Jerusalem Van Leer Foundation
.
Van Leer Jerusalem Foundation
1985a
. The comprehensive educatonal porject on relations between Arabs and Jews and between Isaril and her neighbors
.
Jerusalem
: The Van Leer Foundaiton
.
Van Leer Jerusalem Foundation
, 1985b
. The Van Leer Foundation: A profile (draft)
.
Jerusalem
: The Van Leer Foundation
.
Yiftachel
, O.
1993
. Debate: The concept of ‘ethnic democracy’ and its applicability to the case of Israiel
.
Ethnic and Racial Studies
15
(1
) 125
–136
.
This content is only available as a PDF.
© 1996 Plenum Publishing Corporation. Published under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0) license.
1996
Plenum Publishing Corporation
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the use is non-commercial and the original work is properly cited. For a full description of the license, please visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0.
