Abstract
As collaborative approaches to resolving public disputes become more prevalent, agency officials are finding themselves in unfamiliar terrain. This article offers one conceptualization of agency roles in collaborative processes, drawing from the experiences of natural resource managers and environmental regulators at the federal level. Based on an examination of 65 cases, the authors identify three distinct “hats” that effective agency officials wear in collaborative processes – leader, partner, and stakeholder. The objective and function of each role is assessed, along with the implications of agency facilitation. The most successful agency representatives were able to blend the three primary roles, and did not act as facilitators of the collaborative process.
REFERENCES
Bacow
, L. S.
and
M.
Wheeler
1985
. Environmental dispute resolution
.
New York
: Plenum
.
Bingham
, G. A.
1986
. Resolving environmental disputes: A decade of experience
.
Washington
: The Conservation Foundation
.
Bingham
, G.
and
D. S.
Miller
1987
. Prospects for resolving hazardous waste siting disputes through negotiations
.
Natural Resource Lawyer
. 18
(3
): 473
–489
.
Carpenter
, S. L.
and
W.J.D.
Kennedy
1988
. Managing public disputes: A practical guide to handling conflict and reaching agreements
.
San Francisco
: Jossey‐Bass
.
Chrislip
, D. D.
and
C. E.
Larson
1994
. Collaborative leadership: How citizens and civic leaders can make a difference
.
San Francisco
: Jossey‐Bass
.
Coglianese
, C.
1997
. Assessing consensus: The promise and performance of negotiated rulemaking
.
Duke Law Journal
. 46
(4
): 1255
–1349
.
Fisher
, R.
,
W.
Ury
, and
B.
Patton
1991
. Getting to YES: Negotiating agreement without giving in
. 2nd Ed.
New York
: Penguin
.
Goergen
, M. T.
,
D.W.
Floyd
, and
P.G.
Ashton
1997
. An old model for building consensus and a new role for foresters
.
Journal of Forestry
95
(1
): 8
–12
.
Gore
, A.
1995
. Common sense government: Works better and costs less
.
New York
: Random House
.
Gray
, B.
1989
. Collaborating: Finding common ground for multiparty problems
.
San Francisco
: Jossey‐Bass
.
Harter
, P. J.
1982
. Negotiating regulations: A cure for the malaise
Georgetown Law Journal
71
(1
): 1
–118
.
Heifetz
, R.A.
1994
. Leadership without easy answers
.
Cambridge, Mass
.
: Belknap/Harvard
.
Innes
, J.E.
1992
. Group processes and the social construction of growth management: Florida, Vermont, and New Jersey
.
Journal of the American Planning Association
58
(4
): 440
–54
.
Kayser
, T.A.
1994
. Building team power: How to unleash the collaborative genius of work teams
.
Homewood, Ill
.
: Irwin
.
Kouzes
, J.
and
B.
Posner
1987
. The leadership challenge: How to get extraordinary things done in organizations
.
San Francisco
: Jossey‐Bass
.
Lax
, D.
and
J. K.
Sebenius
1986
. The manager as negotiator
.
New York
: The Free Press
.
Lewicki
, R. J.
,
J.A.
Litterer
,
J.W.
Minton
and
D.M.
Saunders
1994
. Negotiation
. 2nd Ed.
Burr Ridge,Ill
.
: Irwin
.
McCloskey
, M.
1996
. The skeptic: Collaboration has its limits
.
High Country News
28
(9
): 7
.
Ozawa
, C.
1991
. Recasting science: Consensual procedures in public policy making
.
Boulder, Colo
.
: Westview
.
Rabe
, B.
1994
. Beyond NIMBY: Hazardous waste siting in Canada and the United States
.
Washington
: Brookings
.
Ryan
, C.M.
1996
. Leadership in regulatory negotiations at the Environmental Protection Agency: An analysis of roles
.
Unpublished doctoral dissertation. The University of Michigan, School of Natural Resources and Environment
.
Shannon
, M. A.
1992
. Foresters as strategic thinkers, facilitators, and citizens
.
Journal of Forestry
90
(10
): 24
–27
.
Sirmon
, J.
,
W.E.
Shands
, and
C.
Liggett
1993
. Communities of interests and open decisionmaking
.
Washington
: Pinchot Institute for Conservation
.
Susskind
, L.
and
J.
Cruikshank
1987
. Breaking the impasse: Consensual approaches to resolving public disputes
.
New York
: Basic Books
.
Susskind
, L.
and
G.
McMahon
1985
. The theory and practice of negotiated rulemaking
.
Yate Journal of Regulation
3
(1
): 133
–165
.
Susskind
, L.
,
E.F.
Babbitt
and
P.N.
Segal
1993
. When ADR becomes the law: A review of federal practice
.
Negotiation Journal
9
(1
): 59
–75
.
Terry
, R.W.
1993
. Authentic leadership: Courage in action
.
San Francisco
: Jossey‐Bass
.
Watkins
, M.
and
K.
Winters
1997
. Intervenors with interests and power
.
Negotiation Journal
. 13
(2
): 119
–142
.
Wondolleck
, J. M.
1988
. Public lands conflict and resolution: Managing national forest disputes
.
New York
: Plenum
.
Wondolleck
, J. M.
1996
. The long‐term consequences of using negotiation to resolve national forest planning disputes
.
Paper presented at the Sixth International Symposium on Society and Resource Management, Pennsylvania State University, State College, Penn. 22 May 1996
.
Wondolleck
, J.M.
and
S.L.
Yaffee
1994
. Building bridges across agency boundaries: In search of excellence in the United States Forest Service
.
A research report to the USDA Forest Service, Pacific Northwest Research Station
.
Ann Arbor
: School of Natural Resources and Environment. The University of Michigan
.
Wondolleck
, J.M.
and
S.L.
Yaffee
Forthcoming. Building bridges: Creating partnership and resolving conflict for a sustainable future
.
Washington
: Island Press
.
Yaffee
, S.L.
1994
. The wisdom of the spotted owl: Policy lessons for a new century
.
Washington
: Island Press
.
Yaffee
, S.L.
and
J.M.
Wondolleck
1995
. Building knowledge pools and relationsheds
.
Journal of Forestry
92
(5
): 60
.
Yaffee
, S.L.
and
J.M.
Wondolleck
1996
. Building bridges across agency boundaries
. In Creating a forestry for the twenty‐first century: The science of ecosystem management
, edited by
K.
Kohm
and
J. F.
Franklin
.
Washington
: Island Press
.
This content is only available as a PDF.
© 1999 Plenum Publishing Corporation. Published under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International (CC BY-NC 4.0) license.
1999
Plenum Publishing Corporation
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the use is non-commercial and the original work is properly cited. For a full description of the license, please visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0.
