Negotiation or Mediation?: An Exploration of Factors Affecting the Choice of Conflict Management in International Conflict

Bercovitch, Jacob; Jackson, Richard

doi:10.1111/j.1571-9979.2001.tb00227.x

Abstract

The conditions under which negotiation or mediation are chosen in international conflict have been little studied. Previous research has tended to focus on the motivations and rational calculations of the states involved. Scant attention has been given to examining the effect of the context on this choice. In this article, we present a framework for studying the contextual conditions under which negotiation or mediation are likely to take place. Employing an original data set, we find that negotiation tends to be used when conflicts are relatively simple, of a low intensity, and when both parties are relatively equal in power. Mediation, on the other band, tends to be used in disputes characterized by high complexity, high intensity, long duration, unequal and fractionated parties, and where the willingness of the parties to settle peacefully is in doubt.

REFERENCES

Bartos

,

O.

,

1995

.

Modeling distributive and integrative negotiations

.

Annals of the Amercian Academy of Political and Social Science

542

:

48

–

60

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Bercovitch

,

J.

,

1984

.

Social conflicts and third praties: Strategies of conflict resoulution

. Boulder , Colo :

Westview Press

.

Google Scholar

Bercovitch

,

J.

1991

.

International mediation and dispute settlement: Evaluating the conditions for successful mediation

.

Negotiation Journal

7

(

1

):

17

–

30

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Bercovitch

,

J.

1992

.

The structure and diversity of mediation in international relations

. In

Mediation in international relations: Multiple approaches to conflict management

, edited by

J.

Bercovitch

and

J.

Rubin

. London :

MacMillan

.

Google Scholar

J.

Anagnoson

, and

D.

Wille

,

1991

.

Some conceptual issues and empirical trends in the study of successful mediation in international relations

.

Journal of Peace Research

28

(

1

):

7

–

17

.

Google Scholar

J.

Anagnoson

and

A.

Houston

,

1996

.

The study of international mediation: Theoretical issues and empirical evidence

. In

Resolving international conflicts: The theory and practice of mediation

, edited by

J.

Bercovitch

. Boulder , Colo. :

Lynne Rienner

.

Google Scholar

J.

Anagnoson

and

R.

Jackson

,

1997

.

International conflict:

A chronological encyclopedia of conflicts and their management 1945–1995

. Washington :

Washington Quarterly

.

Google Scholar

J.

Anagnoson

and

Langley

,

J.

,

1993

.

The nature of the dispute and the effectiveness of international mediation

.

Journal of Conflict Resolution

37

:

670

–

691

.

Google Scholar

Bigoness

,

W.

,

1976

.

The impact of initial bargaining position and alternative modes of third party intervention in resolving bargaining impasses

.

Organizational Behavior and Human Performance

17

:

185

–

198

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Bingham

,

G.

,

1986

.

Resolving environmental disputes: A decade of experience

. Washington :

Conservation Foundation

.

Google Scholar

Blake

,

R.

and

J.

Mouton

,

1964

.

The managerial grid. Houston: Gulf

.

Google Scholar

Bonham

,

G.

,

1971

.

Simulating international disarmament negotiations

.

Journal of Conflict Resolution

15

:

299

–

315

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Brams

,

S.

,

1975

.

Game theory and politics

. New York :

Academic Press

.

Google Scholar

Brecher

,

M.

,

J.

Wilkenfeld

, and

A.

Moser

,

1988

.

Crises in the twentieth century

. New York :

Praeger

.

Google Scholar

Brogan

,

P.

,

1992

.

World conflicts: Why and where they are happening

, 2nd Ed. London :

Bloomsbury

.

Google Scholar

Butterworth

,

R.

,

1976

.

Managing interstate disputes, 1945–1974

. Pittsburgh :

University of Pittsburgh Press

.

Google Scholar

Carnevale

,

P.

and

D.

Pruitt

,

1992

.

Negotiation and mediation

.

Annual Review of Psychology

43

:

531

–

82

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Cook

,

C.

and

J.

Paxton

,

1979

.

Commonwealth political facts

. London :

MacMillan

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Day

,

A.

ed,

1987

.

Border and territorial disputes

. 2nd Ed.

Burnt Mill

,

Harlow

, Essex :

Longman

.

Google Scholar

Dixon

,

W.

,

1996

.

Third‐party techniques for preventing conflict escalation and promoting peaceful settlement

.

International Organisation

50

(

4

):

653

–

681

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Druckman

,

D.

,

1973

.

Human factors in international negotiations: Social‐psychological aspects of international conflict

. Beverly Hills , Calif. :

Sage

.

Google Scholar

Langley

,

J.

1983

.

Social psychology and international negotiations

. In

Advances in applied social psychology

, edited by

R.

Kidd

and

M.J.

Saks

. Hillsdale , N.J. :

Erlbaum

.

Google Scholar

Langley

,

J.

1993a

.

The situational levers of negotiating flexibility

.

Journal of Conflict Resolution

37

:

236

–

276

.

Google Scholar

Langley

,

J.

1993b

.

Statistical analysis for negotiation support

.

Theory and Decision

34

:

215

–

233

.

Google Scholar

Langley

,

J.

1997

.

Dimensions of international negotiations: structures, processes, and outcomes

.

Group Decision and Negotiation

6

:

395

–

420

.

Google Scholar

J.

Martin

,

S.

Nan

, and

D.

Yagcioglu

,

1999

.

Dimensions of international negotiation: A test of Iklés typology

.

Group Decision and Negotiation

8

:

89

–

108

.

Google Scholar

Fisher

,

R.

,

1990

.

The social psychology of intergroup and international conflict resolution

. London :

Springer‐Verlag

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Fisher

,

R.

1995

.

Pacific, impartial third‐party intervention in international conflict: A review and analysis

. In

Beyond confrontation: Learning conflict resolution in the post‐cold war era

, edited by

J.

Vasquez

et al., Ann Arbor :

University of Michigan Press

.

Google Scholar

Frankel

,

J.

,

1969

.

International politics: Conflict and harmony

. London :

Allen Lane the Penguin Press

.

Google Scholar

Gulliver

,

P.

,

1979

.

Disputes and negotiations: A cross‐cultural perspective

. New York :

Acadmic Press

.

Google Scholar

Heuer

,

L.

and

S.

Penrod

,

1986

.

Procedural preference as a function of conflict intensity

.

Journal of Personality and Social Psychology

51

(

4

):

700

–

710

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Hiltrop

,

J.

,

1985

.

Mediator behaviour and the settlement of collective bargaining disputes in Britain

.

Journal of Social Issues

41

:

83

–

99

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Hiltrop

,

J.

1989

.

Factors associated with successful labour mediation

. In

Mediation research

, edited by

K.

Kressel

and

D.

Bruitt

. San Francisco :

Jossey‐Bass

.

Google Scholar

Hiltrop

,

J.

, and

J.

Rubin

,

1982

.

Effects of intervention mode and conflict of interest on dispute resolution

.

Journal of Personality and Social Psychology

:

665

–

672

.

Google Scholar

Holsti

,

K.

,

1966

.

Resolving international conflicts: A taxonomy of behaviour and some figures on procedures

.

Journal of Conflict Resolution

10

(

2

):

272

–

296

.

Google Scholar

Johnson

,

D.

and

D.

Pruitt

,

1972

.

Preintervention effects of mediation versus arbitration

.

Journal of Applied Psychology

56

:

1

–

10

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Johnson

,

D.

and

W.

Tullar

,

1972

.

Style and third‐party intervention, face saving, and bargaining behaviour

.

Journal of Experimental and Social Psychology

6

:

319

–

330

.

Google Scholar

Keashly

,

L.

and

R.

Fisher

,

1996

.

A contingency perspective on conflict interventions: Theoretical and practical considerations

. In

Resolving international conflicts: The theory and practice of mediation

, edited by

J.

Bercovitch

. Boulder , Colo. :

Lynne Rienner

.

Google Scholar

Kleiboer

,

M.

,

1996

.

Understanding success and failure of international mediation

.

Journal of Conflict Resolution

40

(

2

):

360

–

389

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Kleiboer

,

M.

and

P.

Hart

,

1995

.

Time to talk? Multiple perspectives on timing of international mediation

.

Cooperation and Conflict

30

:

307

–

48

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Kolb

,

D.

,

1983

.

The mediators

. Cambridge , Mass. :

MIT Press

.

Google Scholar

Kressel

,

K.

and

D.

Pruitt

, eds.,

1989

.

Mediation research: The process and effectiveness of third party intervention

. San Francisco :

Jossey‐Bass

.

Google Scholar

Kriesberg

,

L.

1982

.

Social conflict

. 2nd Ed. Englewood Cliffs , N.J. :

Prentice‐Hall

.

Google Scholar

Lall

,

A.

,

1966

.

Modern international negotiation: Principles and practice

. New York :

Columbia University Press

.

Google Scholar

LaTour

,

S.

,

P.

Houlden

,

L.

Walker

, and

J.

Thibaut

,

1972

.

Some determinants of preference for modes of conflict resolution

.

Journal of Conflict Resolution

20

(

2

):

319

–

356

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Lax

,

D. A.

and

J. K.

Sebenius

,

1986

.

The manager as negotiator

. New York :

The Free Press

.

Google Scholar

Mitchell

,

C. R.

1991

.

The structure of international conflict

. London :

Macmillan

.

Google Scholar

Moore

,

C.

,

1986

.

The mediation process: Practical strategies for resolving conflict

. San Francisco :

Jossey‐Bass

.

Google Scholar

Northedge

,

F.

and

M.

Donelan

,

1971

.

International disputes: The political aspects

. London :

Europa

.

Google Scholar

Organski

,

A.

,

1960

.

World politics

. New York :

Alfred A. Knopf

.

Google Scholar

Ott

,

C.

,

1972

.

Mediation as a method of conflict resolution: Two cases

.

International Organisation

.

24

:

595

–

618

.

Google Scholar

Princen

,

T.

,

1992

.

Intermediaries in international conflict

. Princeton :

Princeton University Press

.

Google Scholar

Pruitt

,

D.

and

P.

Carnevale

,

1993

.

Negotiation in social conflict

. Buckingham , UK :

Open University Press

.

Google Scholar

N.

McGuillicudy

,

G.

Welton

, and

W.

Fry

,

1989

.

Process of mediation in dispute settlement centers

. In

Mediation research

, edited by

K.

Kressel

and

D.

Pruitt

. San Francisco :

Jossey‐Bass

.

Google Scholar

Rahim

,

M.

,

1983

.

A measure of styles of handling interpersonal conflict

.

Academy of Management Journal

26

(

2

):

368

–

376

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

PubMed

Raiffa

,

H.

,

1982

.

The art and science of negotiation

. Cambridge , Mass. :

Harvard University Press

.

Google Scholar

Ramberg

,

B.

,

1978

.

The seabeds arms control negotiations: A study of multilateral arms control diplomacy

. Monograph Series in World Affairs 15, book 2. Denver , Colo. :

University of Denver

.

Google Scholar

Rapoport

,

A.

,

1960

.

Fights, games and debates

. Ann Arbor :

University of Michigan Press

.

Google Scholar

Raymond

,

G.

and

C.

Kegley

,

1985

.

Third‐party mediation and international norms: A test of two models

.

Conflict Management and Peace Science

9

:

33

–

51

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Rubin

,

J.

,

1980

.

Experimental research on third‐party intervention in conflict: Toward some generalizations

.

Psychological Bulletin

87

:

379

–

391

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

PubMed

Rubin

,

J.

1992

.

Conclusion: International mediation in context

. In

Mediation in international relations: Multiple approaches to conflict management

, edited by

J.

Bercovitch

and

J.

Rubin

. London :

MacMillan

.

Google Scholar

Rubin

,

J.

and

B.

Brown

,

1975

.

The social psychology of bargaining and negotiation

. New York :

Academic Press

.

Google Scholar

D.

Pruitt

, and

S.

Kim

,

1994

.

Social conflict: Escalation

,

Stalemate and settlement

. 2nd ed. New York :

McGraw‐Hill

.

Google Scholar

Sawyer

,

J.

and

H.

Guetzkow

,

1965

.

Bargaining and negotiation in international relations

. In

International behaviour: A social‐psychological analysis

, edited by

H.

Kelman

. New York :

Holt, Rinehart, and Winston

.

Google Scholar

Schelling

,

T.

,

1960

.

The strategy of conflict

. New York :

Oxford University Press

.

Google Scholar

Sherman

,

F.

,

1987

.

Pathway to peace: The United Nations and the road to nowhere? Doctorial dissertation, University of Pittsburgh

.

Google Scholar

Siebe

,

W.

,

1991

.

Game theory

. In

International negotiation: Analysis, approaches, issues

, edited by

V.

Kremenyuk

. San Francisco :

Jossey‐Bass

.

Google Scholar

Stephens

,

J.

,

1988

.

Acceptance of mediation initiatives: A preliminary framework

. In

New approaches to international mediation

, edited by

C.

Mitchell

and

K.

Webb

. New York :

Greenwood Press

.

Google Scholar

Thibaut

,

J.

and

L.

Walker

,

1975

.

Procedural justice: A psychological analysis

. Hillsdale , N.J. :

Erlbaum

.

Google Scholar

Thibaut

,

J.

and

Thibaut

,

J.

1978

.

A theory of procedure

.

California Law Review

66

:

541

–

566

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Thomas

,

K.

,

1976

.

Conflict and conflict management

. In

Handbook of industrial and organizational psychology

, edited by

H.

Dunnett

. Chicago :

Rand McNally College

.

Google Scholar

Tillema

,

H.

,

1991

.

International armed conflict since 1945: A bibliographic handbook of wars and military interventions

. Boulder , Colo. :

Westview

.

Google Scholar

Touval

,

S.

,

1982

.

The peace brokers: Mediators in the Arab‐Israeli conflict 1948–1979

. Princeton :

Princeton University Press

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Touval

,

S.

and

I. W.

Zartman

,

1989

.

Mediation in international conflicts

. In

Mediation research

, edited by

K.

Kressel

and

D.

Pruitt

. San Francisco :

Jossey‐Bass

.

Google Scholar

Wall

,

J.

,

1981

.

Mediation: An analysis, review and proposed research

.

Journal of Conflict Resolution

25

:

157

–

180

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Wall

,

J.

and

A.

Lynn

,

1993

.

Mediation: A current review

.

Journal of Conflict Resolution

37

(

1

):

160

–

194

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Wright

,

Q.

,

1965

.

The escalation of international conflicts

.

Journal of Conflict Resolution

9

:

434

–

449

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Young

,

O.

,

1967

.

The intermediaries: Third parties in international crises

. Princeton :

Princeton University Press

.

Google Scholar

Crossref

Young

,

O.

ed.,

1975

.

Bargaining: Formal theories of negotiation

. Urbana , III. :

University of Illinois Press

.

Google Scholar

Zacher

,

M.

1979

.

International conflict and collective security, 1946–1977

. New York :

Praeger

.

Google Scholar

Zartman

,

I. W.

,

198

.

Explaining disengagement

. In

Dynamics of third party intervention: Kissinger in the Middle East

, edited by

J.

Rubin

. New York :

Praeger

.

Google Scholar

Zartman

,

I. W.

and

S.

Touval

,

1996

.

International mediation in the post‐cold war era

. In

Managing global chaos

, edited by

C.

Crocker

,

F.

Hampson

, and

P.

Aall

. Washington :

U.S. Institute of Peace Press

.

Google Scholar

This content is only available as a PDF.

2001

Plenum Publishing Corporation

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For a full description of the license, please visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode.

Negotiation or Mediation?: An Exploration of Factors Affecting the Choice of Conflict Management in International Conflict

Abstract

REFERENCES

Cited By

A product of The MIT Press

MIT Press Direct

Information

MIT Press

Contact Us

Negotiation or Mediation?: An Exploration of Factors Affecting the Choice of Conflict Management in International Conflict

Abstract

REFERENCES

Cited By

Related Articles

A product of The MIT Press

MIT Press Direct

Information

MIT Press

Contact Us

This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only