Abstract
This essay argues that generalizations about cultural identities and values should play a key role in designing procedures to resolve disputes. Generalizations about cultures are risky given the complexity of memberships and group boundaries, not to mention the power dynamics within and between social groups. But it is important to take the risk: attempts to avoid or transcend culture in resolving disputes pose an even greater danger, of reiterating the understandings of dominant cultural groups under the guise of neutrality. The author explores the “politics of cultural generalization” in theoretical terms, then considers its implications for concrete elements of dispute resolution training and process design.
REFERENCES
Abel
, R. E.
, 1982
. The politics of informal justice, vol. 1: The American experience
.
London
: Academic Press, Inc
.
Alberta Law Reform Institute
1990
. Dispute resolution: A directory of methods, projects and resources
. Research paper no. 19.
Edmonton
: Alberta Law Reform Institute
.
Avruch
, K.
1991
. Introduction: Culture and conflict resolution
. In Conflict resolution: Cross‐cultural perspectives
, edited by
K.
Avruch
,
P.W.
Black
, and
J.
Scimecca
.
New York
: Greenwood Press
.
Avruch
, K.
1998
. Culture and conflict resolution
.
Washington
: U.S. Institute of Peace Press
.
Avruch
, K.
and
P.W.
Black
1995
. Conflict resolution in intercultural settings: Problems and prospects
. In Conflict resolution theory and practice: Integration and application
, edited by
D.
Sandole
and
H.
van der Merwe
.
Manchester
: Manchester University Press
.
Bell
, C.
and
D.
Kahane
, eds.
Forthcoming
.
Intercultural dispute resolution in aboriginal contexts
.
Vancouver
: University of British Columbia Press
.
Benhabib
, S.
1992
. Situating the self: Gender, community and postmodernism in contemporary ethics
.
Cambridge
: Polity
.
Bennett
, M.
1986
. A developmental approach to training for intercultural sensitivity
.
International Journal of Intercultural Relations
10
: 179
–196
.
Broome
, B.J.
1995
. Managing differences in conflict resolution: The role of relational empathy
. In Conflict resolution theory and practice: Integration and application
, edited by
D.
Sandole
and
H.
van der Merwe
.
Manchester
: Manchester University Press
.
Bryan
, P.E.
1992
. Killing us softly: Divorce mediation and the politics of power
.
Buffalo Law Review
40
: 441
–523
.
Connolly
, W.E.
1995
. The ethos of pluralization
.
Minneapolis
: University of Minnesota Press
.
Deveaux
, M.
2000
. Conflicting equalities? Cultural group rights and sex equality
.
Political Studies
48
(3
): 522
–539
.
Fisher
, R.
,
W.
Ury
, and
B.
Patton
1991
. Getting to YES: Negotiating agreement without giving in
. 2nd. Ed.
New York
: Penguin
.
Forment
, C.A.
1996
. Peripheral peoples and narrative identities in late modernity: An Arendtian reading
. In Democracy and difference: Contesting the boundaries of the political
, edited by
S.
Benhabib
.
Princeton
: Princeton University Press
.
Frankenberg
, R.
1993
. White women, race matters: The social construction of whiteness
.
Minneapolis
: University of Minnesota Press
.
Gilroy
, P.
1993
. The black Atlantic: Modernity and double consciousness
.
Cambridge
,
Mass.
: Harvard University Press
.
Goldberg
, D.T.
1993
. Racist culture: Philosophy and the politics of meaning
.
Oxford
: Blackwell
.
Grillo
, T.
1991
. The mediation alternative: process dangers for women
.
Yale Law Journal
100
(6
): 1545
–610
.
Gutmann
, A.
1999
. How not to resolve moral conflicts in politics
.
Ohio State Journal on Dispute Resolution
15
(1
): 1
–18
.
Gutmann
, A.
and
D.
Thompson
1996
. Democracy and disagreement
.
Cambridge
,
Mass.
: Harvard University Press
.
Habermas
, J.
1994
. Justification and application: Remarks on discourse ethics
, translated by
C.P.
Cronin
.
Cambridge
,
Mass.
: MIT Press
.
Harding
, S.
1993
. Rethinking standpoint epistemology: “What is strong objectivity?”
In Feminist epistemologies
, edited by
L.
Alcoff
and
E.
Potter
.
New York
: Routledge
.
Heyes
, C.J.
2000
. Line drawings: Defining women through feminist practice
.
Ithaca
: Cornell University Press
.
Heyes
, C.J.
ed.
2003
. The grammar of politics: Wittgenstein and political philosophy
.
Itaca
: Cornell University Press
.
Kahane
, D.
1996
. Cultivating liberal virtues
.
Canadian Journal of Political Science/Revue canadienne de science politique
1996
: 699
–728
.
Kahane
, D.
1999
. Diversity and civic solidarity
.
Journal of Political Philosophy
7
(3
): 243
–262
.
Kahane
, D.
2000
. Pluralism, deliberation, and citizen competence: Recent developments in democratic theory
.
Social Theory and Practice
26
(3
): 509
–526
.
Kymlicka
, W.
1996
. Multicultural citizenship
.
Oxford
: Oxford University Press
.
Le Baron
Duryea M.
1992
. Conflict and culture: A literature review and bibliography
.
Victoria
,
B.C.
: University of Victoria Institute for Dispute Resolution
.
Lederach
, J. P.
1995
. Preparing for peace: Conflict transformation across cultures
.
Syracuse
: Syracuse University Press
.
Lloyd
, G.
1984
. The man of reason: “Male” and “female” in western philosophy
.
Minneapolis
: University of Minnesota Press
.
MacIntyre
, A.
1988
. Whose justice? Which rationality
?
Notre Dame
: University of Notre Dame Press
.
Marx
, K.
1977
. On the Jewish question
.
Selected writings
.
Oxford
: Oxford University Press
.
Merry
, S.E.
1987
. Disputing without culture
.
Harvard Law Review
100
: 2057
–2073
.
Nader
, L.
1991
. Harmony models and the construction of law
. In Conflict resolution: Cross‐cultural perspectives
, edited by
K.
Avruch
,
P.W.
Black
, and
J.A.
Scimecca
.
New York
: Greenwood Press
.
Nader
, L.
1993
. Controlling processes in the practice of law: Hierarchy and pacification in the movement to re‐form dispute ideology
.
Ohio State Journal on Dispute Resolution
9
(1
): 1
–25
.
Nussbaum
, M.
1992
. Human functioning and social justice: In defense of Aristotelian essentialism
.
Political Theory
20
(2
): 202
–246
.
Nussbaum
, M.
, ed.
1996
. For love of country: Debating the limits of patriotism
.
Boston
: Beacon Press
.
Okin
, S. M.
1999
. Is multiculturalism bad for women
? In Is multiculturalism bad for women
, edited by
J.
Cohen
,
M.
Howard
, and
M.C.
Nussbaum
.
Princeton
: Princeton University Press
.
New York
: Basic Books
.
Oman
, N.
Forthcoming. Paths to cultural understanding: Feasting, shared horizons, and unforced consensus
. In Intercultural dispute resolution in aboriginal context
, edited by
C.
Bell
and
D.
Kahane
.
Vancouver
: University of British Columbia Press
.
Omi
, M.
and
H.
Winant
1994
. Racial formation in the United States: From the 1960s to the 1990s
.
New York
: Routledge
.
Rawls
, J.
1987
. The idea of an overlapping consensus
.
Oxford Journal of Legal Studies
7
: 11
–25
.
Rubinstein
, R.E.
1995
. The analyzing and resolving of class conflict
. In Conflict resolution theory and practice: Integration and application
, edited by
D.
Sandole
and
H.
van der Merwe
.
Manchester
: Manchester University Press
.
Sartre
, J‐P.
1948
. Anti‐Semite and Jew
, translated by
George
J. Becker
.
New York
: Schocken Books
.
Scimecca
, J.A.
1991
. Conflict resolution in the United States: The emergence of a profession
. In Conflict resolution: Cross‐cultural perspectives
, edited by
K.
Avruch
,
P.W.
Black
, and
J.A.
Scimecca
.
New York
: Greenwood Press
.
Shapiro
, M.J.
1997
. Bowling blind: Post liberal civil society and the worlds of neo‐Tocquevillean social theory
.
Theory and Event
1
:1
.
Stout
, J.
1988
. Ethics after Babel: The languages of morals and their discontents
.
Boston
: Beacon Press
.
Sunstein
, C.R.
1995
. Incompletely theorized agreements
.
Harvard Law Review
108
: 1733
–1772
.
Susskind
, L.
and
J.
Cruikshank
Breaking the impasse: Consensual approaches to resolving public disputes
.
New York
: Basic Books
.
Taylor
, C.
1989a
. Cross‐purposes: The liberal‐communitarian debate
. In Liberalism and the moral life
, edited by
N.
Rosenblum
.
Cambridge
,
Mass.
: Harvard University Press
.
Taylor
, C.
1989b
. Sources of the self: The making of the modern identity
.
Cambridge
,
Mass.
: Harvard University Press
.
Taylor
, C.
1992
. Multiculturalism and “the politics of recognition
.”
Princeton
: Princeton University Press
.
Todorov
, T.
1993
. On human diversity: Nationalism, racism, and exoticism in French thought
, translated by
C.
Porter
.
Cambridge
,
Mass.
: Harvard University Press
.
Tully
, J.
1989
. Wittgenstein and political philosophy: Understanding practices of critical reflection
.
Political Theory
17
(2
): 172
–204
.
Tully
, J.
1995
. Strange multiplicity: Constitutionalism in an age of diversity
.
Cambridge
: Cambridge University Press
.
Weiss
, A.
2001
. Macht und differenz. Ein erweitertes modell der konfliktpotentiale in interkulturellen auseinandersetzungen. Berghof Report 7. Berlin: Berghof Research Center for Constructive Conflict Management (available online at http://www.berghof‐center.org).
Young
, I.M.
1990
. Justice and the politics of difference
.
Princeton
: Princeton University Press
.
Young
, I.M.
1996
. Asymmetrical reciprocity: On moral respect, wonder, and enlarged thought
.
Constellations: An International Journal of Critical and Democratic Theory
3
(1
): 340
–363
.
This content is only available as a PDF.
© 2003 Plenum Publishing Corporation
2003
Plenum Publishing Corporation
This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For a full description of the license, please visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode.